Third time’s the charm? Intellectuals and Ethiopia’s Plight

By Teshome Bedada, Email: [email protected]
November 2017 Toronto Canada
In his famous play called hahu weyim pepu, Laureate Tsegaye Gebremedhin metaphorically captured Ethiopia as a mother that consecutively miscarried pregnancies of democracy. In a period shy of half-century, we’ve witnessed two such ‘miscarriages’. Yet again, Ethiopia is in a third ‘labor’; the TPLF regime has being facing mounting pressures over the last two years, and change is in the air. Third time’s a charm, or is it? What will transpire depends on a number of factors, not least of which is whether the Ethiopian intelligentsia plays an active, concerted role in not only seeing off the tyrant ruling clique but also ensuring a successful transition to a democratic system. Ethiopia is in a desperate need of ‘midwives’ to successfully ‘deliver’ democracy, and no one group is better positioned than the intelligentsia to discharge such a responsibility.  Ethiopian intellectuals have a great responsibility, perhaps now more so than ever. Articles by, for example, Prof. Alemayehu G Mariam and Prof. Messay Kebede have called for fellow intellectuals to shoulder their fair share of responsibilities. Prof. Birhanu Nega publicly lamented the limited role of Ethiopian intellectuals on the critical issues of Ethiopia and made a plea for a more active engagement. Whereas it is important to plead with the intellectuals and remind them of their moral responsibility, a more fruitful approach can be devised by understanding the underlying reasons for their limited active role.

Theories in behavioural science suggest that individuals fail to act either because they do not want to (an incentive problem) or they do not know how to (a bounded-rationality problem). These two factors can help explain the limited, if any, involvement of most Ethiopian intellectuals. The first problem is that of incentives. Clearly, individuals respond to incentives. What kind of incentives are appropriate here? Well, these incentives can take a form of positive or negative reinforcements. Whereas positive reinforcements constitute both financial and non-financial returns, the non-financial returns are more relevant here as we are considering intellectuals’ moral responsibility for which financial incentives are hardly required. So, what non-financial incentives can attract more intellectuals to come to the fore? One such incentive may take a form of identifying role models and celebrating those intellectuals who have contributed immensely to Ethiopia. By honoring such intellectuals of the past and the present, we can inspire a generation of intellectuals who would want to emulate their achievements. Here it’s important to face head-on a major problem we Ethiopians have related to honoring our heroes and heroines; instead of emphasizing the excellent achievements of many, we spend too much time and energy in finding faults and criticizing. Most of us harbor a scarcity mentality and a zero-sum game thinking in that someone else’s gain, we think, is our loss. The Amharic adage, weta weta yalech mashila andim le wefe andim le wenchif, captures this sentiment. According to Platteau, such social norms discourage individual effort. Therefore, if we really want to encourage intellectuals to take active roles, then we have to do away with such norms and start honoring those who have given a lot to Ethiopia.
 
There is no shortage of such intellectuals in Ethiopia. For example, Tsehafi Taezaz Aklilu Habte-Wold (1912 – 1974) is one of such intellectuals who have made considerable contributions to Ethiopia. His role in improving the diplomatic relationship of Ethiopia with the USA was impressive. His contribution to the formation of the Organization of African Union (OAU) and advancing Ethiopia’s stature in the process was remarkable. He was also a major player in the establishment of the Ethiopian Airlines, which has been a pride of Ethiopia for years. His diplomacy skills and unrelenting effort had also been instrumental in bringing Eritrea into federation with Ethiopia. These are but some of his hefty achievements. Another intellectual with an impressive record is Kibour Yilma Deressa (1907 – 1979), who assumed several government positions including a stint as a Ministry of Foreign Affairs. A son of Blatta Deressa Amante (an influential thinker himself) and a contemporary of Aklilu, Yilma had substantially contributed to the development of such financial institutions as the Ministry of Finance and the National Bank. As well, he was the driving force behind the introduction of the Ethiopian currency, birr. He had also played a considerable role in the formation of OAU. These Ethiopians made huge contributions to their country during their time. The current ruling party has been instigating conflicts among the many ethnic groups who lived harmoniously for centuries in its attempt to weaken the unity of the country.  Prof Berhanu Nega and Dr. Merera Gudina have worked tirelessly to expose TPLF’S conspiracy in promoting hate, human rights violation and corruption. Their persistent, courageous fight for freedom which lasted decades is exemplary to the current generation. These are but examples and one can identify a host of other intellectuals with substantial contributions to Ethiopia. I do not think that we’ve accorded these intellectuals the due respect and honor they deserve. By failing to do so, we would not only take their achievements for granted but also deprive future generations of intellectual’s role models to look up to. As well, we need to move away from considering intellectuals in aggregate and consider (and honor) the remarkable achievements of many.
 
Another challenge limiting the involvement of intellectuals in national matters is lack of awareness and/or requisite skill sets to scale up activities. A discussion I had with a friend on the issue surfaced one of the assumptions underlying political involvement of intellectuals. There is a tendency to relegate politics to an issue of concern only to those in political science and related areas. ‘I am an engineer and thus have nothing to do with politics’, argued my friend. Well, I think my friend is by no means alone in this. Many from both social science and natural science disciplines hold such a believe. The argument is reasonable in that it advances the notion that individual’s involvement should be merit based; that is, an intellectual in political science has a more relevant training in the area of politics and thus need to be politically more active. In fact, this is the kind of merit-based system we miss in the TPLF regime and this is what we aspire to have. However, the argument is based on a narrow, misguided understanding of politics. Politics is not something we consignee to a select group of individuals. Rather, it is about power (possession, division, and distribution) which can be used to get things done, formulate and implement policies, and efficiently allocate the limited resource available to the country under consideration. Such power can take a form of legitimate power, expert power, and charismatic power. Intellectuals do have the expert power. They can use such power to undermine the (il)legitimate power of a tyrant. Intellectuals can ask the right questions, critically examine the (false) claims of such tyrants as TPLF and debunk their propaganda. Intellectuals can play a major diplomatic role by exposing the lies of the TPLF regime and showing the practical merits for foreign governments of doing away with the regime. Intellectuals can also play roles in weakening the fundamental economic, military, information, and political pillars of TPLF. For example, an engineer specializing in communication technologies is in a better position to understand, neutralize, and counter TPLF’s mischiefs and attacks related to network and communication. Whatever action that can tip the power balance in favour of Ethiopians is considered a political action. Just because one does not belong to the fields from which politicians has traditionally emerged, it doesn’t mean that s/he has no role to play in influencing the balance of power. Intellectuals need to realize that the expert power they have at their disposal can make a difference.
 
In sum, realizing a free and democratic Ethiopia requires more than merely chiding intellectuals. In fact, we need to look into the root causes of the status quo (i.e., the very limited involvement of intellectuals in the political affairs of Ethiopia). By identifying two potential sources of this problem and forwarding potential recommendations, this article moves a step toward resolving the issue. If Ethiopia is to avoid a third ‘miscarriage’, then its intellectuals need to do more.

0 Comments

  1. Mr. Bedada,
    Excellent article.
    I agree with you that Ethiopian Intellectuals are not contributing at all to the advancement of Ethiopia. Very few are, may be 0.0000001%. Why is that?
    1. Successive Ethiopian governments have been and continue to be anti intellectuals. They see intellectuals as a treat to their power not as an asset. The student/intellectual movement of the 1960’s which was designed to bring land reform and economic opportunity to vast majority of Ethiopians was considered by HAILE SELASSIE REGIME as a movement by trouble makers and not by reformers. The student/intellectual movement of 1977-1978 was crushed by Red Terror, the mass killing of thousand of Ethiopian intellectuals. Mengistu killed and jailed lots of Ethiopian intellectuals soon after he took power. The criminal/mafia TPLF/EPRDF has been killing/jailing/torturing intellectuals since 2001. WE ALL GREW UP KNOWING THAT IT AIN’T COOL TO FREELY EXERCISE YOUR INTELLECT. IT IS SAFER TO KEEP IT TO YOURSELF AND TO YOUR NARROW PROFESSION. Ethiopian intellectuals have been conditioned and programmed to be fearful and coward b/c they don’t want to end up where their intellectual ancestors ended up, DEAD or in JAIL.
    2. A lot of our intellectuals may be selfish. I made it so the the hell with everybody else.
    3. A lot of our intellectuals are benefiting by investing in the many illegal and corrupt businesses of the criminal/terrorist TPLF/EPRDF. THEY ARE PART AND PARCEL OF OUR PROBLEM.
    4. Laziness. I work for me and my family. I don’t want to spend my time, energy and money helping others.
    5. Stupidity. Being an intellectual in a specific field of study such as engineering does not mean you are an intelligent person. You may zero common sense, you may be narrow minded with no ability to see the big picture, you knowledge of government and history may be zero. Consequently, you may not appreciate the importance of democracy, freedom, culture, rule of law, meritocracy,honoring our heroes and making them a role models to our children and grandchildren to the progress and advancement of ALL Ethiopians people.
    LET US FOLLOW THE EXAMPLE OF BRITISH GOVERNMENT. THEY HONOR BRITISH CITIZENS ALL OVER THE GLOBE WHO ACCOMPLISHED A GREAT DEAL IN THEIR LIFE TIME THEREBY BRINGING HONOR TO BRITISH PEOPLE BY CALLING THEM “SIR”. For example original Beatles musician Paul McCartney was Knighted Sir Paul McCartney by Queen Elizabeth the II on March 11, 2004

  2. There is a Price to Pay for Intellectual Prostitution and Academic Bullshits !
    Yoseph M. Baba Busha, Ph.D.
    Tears fall off my eyes every time I see African youth as well as African children who are suffering under political domination and economic exploitation due to neo-colonial policies. Westerners and their brainwashed followers called Westernized-Africans minority, who are fighting tooth and nail to implement neo-colonial policies to loot the national treasuries and the natural resources, have manipulated the machinery of government to serve private interests. They are wreaking havoc all over Africa. The uncomfortable truth is that many Westernized African intellectuals, who brainwashed, manipulated, slaughtered, and downplayed the African sons and daughters, in collaboration with unscrupulous local leaders, have also done great damage to the continent of Africa.
    These Westernized African coward “scholars” are intellectually unfit to resist neo-colonialism and pseudo-international communities. As the faithful servants of neo-colonialism and agents of imperialism, they have sabotaged the true independence of Africa. They betrayed Mama Africa for cheap food donations and used clothes!
    Westernized African “intellectuals”, who are the greatest imperialists of human history, are unable to fight neo-colonial polices. Of course, being educated in the neoliberal universities, we do not expect such obsequious “thinkers”to be more critical on the issues of neo-colonization or to carry out anti-neocolonial scholarship. Let alone to be critical of Western scholarship, there are“African scholars” who make black people ashamed of being African and induce in them a psychatristic yearinig to be white, to attain whiteness. What an intellectual prostitution and academic bullshit/s!
    Great African thinkers, like Fanon, warned of the coming of political mess and the social crisis of which stems from (post)colonial African condition. They proved themselves prophets! These great thinkers had time and time cautioned the danger of neo-colonialism in (post)colonial Africa. The present African social reality as well as the global relations in our current moment compell all of us to turn towards these great thinkers and revisit their critical thoughts. Their words must be taken into account if the present generation wants to thoroughly understand and critically interpret the urgency of dealing with neo-colinial policies. Neo-colonialism is the greatest evil of our times. If we want to assure the future of Africa, we ought to understand that the root-causes of the presnt social-political crisis of African continent are nothing other than neo-colonial polices.
    World Bank and IMF policies have created an environment of unfair trade which destroyed Africans ability to become economically independent. There is no other philosophical explanation for our economic crisis other than what I have just stated. No other explanation as certain alarmist propaganda would lead us to believe! Never! Never! Westernized African elites can hardly become true critical thinkers and social-political liberators from neo-colonialism polices. Shame on you!
    This is one of the main reasons why some great African thinkers, who discovered the root-causes of African political instability and who paved the way for true“democracy,” have been assassinated by suspected Western organized plots. When one knows why and how they struggled and died, she or he comes to realize the true meaning of the so called neo-colonialism.
    If there is a lesson here, there has been great intellectual manipulation in (post)colonial era by Westernized African “thinkers,” who no longer question or thoroughly investigate the deplorable condition of contemporary Africa. The business of these “thinkers,” is to destroy the reality! Period! This is a shocking danger we (Pan-Africanists) are facing! The willful and active collaboration of African intellectuals has resulted in most painful and treacherous aspect of Post-colonial Africa.
    Yet, lest we forget the words of Sayyid Mohamed Abdille Hassen, a Somali anti-coloialist leader 1899-1920 (taken from an Open Letter to the English people)
    “I say, listen to my words and mark them. We have fought for a year. I wish to rule my country and protect my religion. We have both suffered considerably in battle with one another. I have no forts, no houses. I have no cultivated fields, no silver or gold for you to take. If the country was cultivated or contained houses or property, it would be worth your while to fight. The country is all jungle, and that is no use to you. If you want wood and stone you can get them in plenty. There are also ant-heaps. The sun is very hot. All you can get from me is war, nothing else.”
    All the Westerners and Westernized Africans get from us in future is nothing, but WAR!
    I REST MY CASE !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.